Comparing yourself to other people you see, whether that's online or in your own mind, is a surefire way to kill your focus and confidence. We're all different, and the way we train should reflect that. Our ambassador Kate explains why comparison is the enemy of progress.
We’ve all been there. You’re enjoying your training, you feel like you’re making progress, you’re proud of what you’re doing and, for once, you’re actually just focusing on yourself. Then you open Instagram. Someone has run further than you. Someone has trained twice that day. Someone’s threshold pace is faster than yours. Someone is lifting heavier, doing more volume, recovering quicker.
Suddenly, the training you were perfectly happy with ten minutes ago doesn’t feel like enough. Should I be doing more? Is my training actually working? Should my sessions be longer? Harder? Should I be doing what they’re doing? I’ve definitely fallen into this trap before, and I think it’s one of the biggest dangers of comparison in sport. Because while looking at other athletes can be incredibly inspiring, comparison can very quickly distract you from the thing that actually matters: your own progress.
I’m a huge believer that consistency over time is one of the most important ingredients for progress. Choose a sensible training approach, commit to it, and give it enough time to actually work. The problem is that comparison can make this really difficult because, when you’re constantly looking at what other people are doing, it’s very easy to develop a ‘grass is greener’ mentality.
You see somebody doing huge mileage and wonder whether you should run more. You see someone doing loads of strength work and start questioning whether you’re strong enough. You see a horrible-looking conditioning session and think, maybe I need to be doing that too. Before you know it, you’ve lost faith in a plan that may have been designed specifically for you. I’ve made this mistake myself. I’ve looked at other people’s training and thought I should be doing more, or doing things differently, without really stopping to ask whether those things are actually right for me.
Because if you constantly jump between approaches, add random sessions or change direction every time you see someone doing something different, how do you ever know whether your own training is working? Progress rarely comes from one heroic week of training; it comes from turning up, week after week, month after month. Comparison can distract you from doing exactly that.
This is probably the thing I have to remind myself of most often: you do not have the full picture. You don’t know somebody else’s exact goals. You don’t know their strengths and weaknesses. You don’t know their injury history, their recovery capacity, their schedule, their training age or what the rest of their week looks like and, fundamentally, their body is not your body.
I’m doing loads of wall balls at the moment because they’re a weakness of mine and, probably more importantly, an area where I’ve previously had a bit of a mental block. I want to improve them physically, but I also want to build confidence in them. Does that mean everyone should suddenly start doing loads of wall balls? Absolutely not. Equally, I know certain things about my own body now because I’ve spent years training it.
I know that lots of free-weight work can aggravate my back. I know that combining high running mileage with lots of strength work leaves me extremely fatigued. I know I need a proper rest day, whereas somebody else might thrive on active recovery. That knowledge is valuable, so throwing it away because I’ve seen somebody else’s training on Instagram makes absolutely no sense.
This is a big one for me personally because I’m a full-time teacher. I train alongside a job that takes up a huge amount of my time and energy, and there are plenty of days where the hours outside work aren’t really ‘free’ hours at all. There’s marking, planning and everything else that comes with teaching, and sometimes I’m simply knackered. I race against people whose lives and working patterns look completely different from mine. It can be incredibly tempting to compare what I’m doing with what they’re doing, particularly when we’re competing in the same races.
But trying to match somebody else’s training volume when I don’t have their lifestyle or recovery time isn’t going to magically make me a better athlete. More likely, I’ll burn the candle at both ends until eventually I’m too exhausted to train properly at all. My training therefore has to be adapted around my life, not the imaginary life I’d have if I didn’t work full-time, and not another athlete’s life. Mine. And I think this matters because the goal isn’t to put together the most impressive-looking training week possible; the goal is to put together weeks you can repeat. Consistency over time, not hero weeks.
Comparison doesn’t just influence what we do; it can influence how we do it. Take running. You might see somebody posting a threshold session at 3:40/km while yours is around 4:00/km. If you decide that 3:40/km is therefore what ‘good’ looks like and try to copy it, you may completely change the purpose of your session. Their threshold pace isn’t your threshold pace, and the same applies to Zone 2.
Your easy pace should be determined by your physiology and your current fitness, not by whatever pace somebody else happened to post on Strava that morning. Going faster doesn’t automatically make a session better; sometimes it just makes it a different session. There is far more value in understanding your own heart-rate zones, paces and training objectives than there is in worrying about somebody else’s. And social media makes this particularly difficult because we’re often comparing our full reality with a tiny, curated snapshot of somebody else’s.
You might be looking at their best session on their best day. They might be tapered, exceptionally well rested or feeling amazing. That might be the only hard session they’ve done all week. You simply don’t know.
This applies just as much to results because it’s incredibly easy to see somebody’s race time and compare it directly with your own without considering what came before it. People often talk about having ‘done HYROX for two years’, for example, as though everybody started from the same place two years ago.
They didn’t. Someone might have two years of HYROX experience but twenty years of high-level sport behind them. They might already have an enormous aerobic base, years of strength training or thousands upon thousands of hours of learning how to train and compete. I’m a good example of this myself. My HYROX journey might have started relatively recently, but my sporting journey absolutely did not. I came into it with years of competitive sport already behind me.
Starting points matter, and timing matters too. You might be comparing your race in November with somebody who has specifically planned to peak in November, while your biggest target isn’t until July. They might have just completed a huge running block. They might have tapered perfectly into that race while you’re training straight through it. A result tells you what somebody did on that day, but it doesn’t tell you everything that led to it.
Perhaps the biggest issue with comparison is how quickly it can change the way you feel about your own achievements. A session can objectively go brilliantly. You can hit your targets, improve on last week and leave feeling proud of yourself, then you see that somebody else went faster and suddenly your own progress feels smaller. That is such a dangerous habit to fall into because those feelings of pride matter.
Enjoying your personal wins, however big or small, is part of what keeps you coming back. If every achievement is immediately measured against somebody else’s, there will almost always be somebody faster, stronger or further ahead. And if that leaves you constantly feeling inadequate, eventually training can stop feeling rewarding at all. That matters because motivation feeds consistency, and consistency feeds progress. We all need different things to keep us motivated too. What makes me want to train might be completely different from what motivates somebody else.
Of course, there are times when progress requires doing things we don’t particularly enjoy, but I still think there’s huge value in understanding what makes you tick. Spend more time working that out and less time worrying about what Instagram tells you that you ‘should’ be doing.
There’s another question I think we sometimes forget to ask when we envy somebody else’s results: Would I actually want everything that comes with achieving them? We see the result, but we don’t necessarily see the sacrifices behind it. Somebody may have made choices around work, relationships, social life, food, sleep, money or countless other things that you simply wouldn’t want to make. And that’s okay.
Sport matters enormously to me, but it exists within a much bigger life. So I think it’s really important to keep coming back to your own why. Why are you doing this? What do you actually want from your sport? And are the choices you’re making helping you build that life? Because somebody else’s goals might look impressive while having absolutely nothing to do with yours.
None of this means we should stop looking at other athletes or being inspired by them. I actually think other people can be one of the greatest sources of motivation. Sometimes seeing somebody achieve something incredible gives you that if they can do it, why can’t I? feeling. It expands your idea of what might be possible. Sometimes it’s much simpler than that. If I’m struggling to motivate myself for a horrible session, I’m absolutely capable of thinking, Alice would do it. Alice is one of my closest friends, a competitor and genuinely one of the most dedicated athletes I know.
Sometimes thinking about how hard she works gives me the kick I need to get on with it. But for me, that’s inspiration rather than comparison, and the difference is in what it does to you. If looking at somebody else makes you feel motivated, excited or curious about what you might be capable of, brilliant. If it makes you feel inadequate, panicked, behind or as though everything you’re doing isn’t enough, that’s probably something worth checking.
Because ultimately, sport is your journey. You need to be able to recognise your wins, enjoy your progress and find a way of training that works with your body, your goals and your life, and that keeps you wanting to come back. Surely the biggest win isn’t one race time, one training block or one result. It’s staying in sport for as long as we possibly can, continuing to move, train, compete and challenge ourselves because those things add something positive to our lives.
And if that’s the goal, maybe the person we really need to keep looking at isn’t the person next to us, but ourselves. It’s why I always come back to one of my favourite quotes, which probably sums up the point of all of this better than I can: “The race is long, and in the end it’s only with yourself.”
*By submitting your email address, you agree to receive marketing emails from SPORTS DIRECT. Click here to read our privacy policy & terms and conditions